Inconsistency detected by ld.so: dl-lookup.c: 966: _dl_setup_hash: Assertion `(bitmask_nwords & (bitmask_nwords - 1)) == 0' failed!

[ghost]

Describe the bug

During the nixpkgs bootstrap process, binaries which link against a patchelf'ed librt.so.1 abort with:

Inconsistency detected by ld.so: dl-lookup.c: 966: _dl_setup_hash: Assertion `(bitmask_nwords & (bitmask_nwords - 1)) == 0' failed! #368 

Steps To Reproduce

1. Set your NIX_PATH explicitly, if you have not yet done so (i.e. such that $NIX_PATH/nixpkgs/ points to a git checkout of nixpkgs).

2. Execute these commands to build the mips64el bootstrap tools, mips64el-nix, and launch a mips64el qemu VM:

# Assumes you have set $NIX_PATH explicitly.  If not, do so.

cd $NIX_PATH/nixpkgs

git fetch https://github.com/a-m-joseph/nixpkgs patchelf-issue-368
git switch -c patchelf-issue-368 FETCH_HEAD

cd /tmp  # or elsewhere
git clone -b patchelf-issue https://github.com/a-m-joseph/mips64-nixpkgs-qemu
cd mips64-nixpkgs-qemu
nix-shell shell.nix --argstr NIXPATH $NIX_PATH

Once the VM boots to a root shell, paste this command:

./demo.sh

You should get:

Inconsistency detected by ld.so: dl-lookup.c: 966: _dl_setup_hash: Assertion `(bitmask_nwords & (bitmask_nwords - 1)) == 0' failed!
error: builder for '/nix/store/76h8qjiv0kr99n87g01qz3sq4z5svikv-bootstrap-tools.drv' failed with exit code 127

This is due to the attempt to patchelf --set-rpath librt.so; if you don't patchelf that, (but instead patchelf other libraries, as I do here), you won't get this error. Note that librt.so has no RPATH prior to patchelf'ing. I suspect that the problem here is some corner case involving --set-rpath on a library that did not have one to begin with.

Expected behavior

The bootstrap completes.

patchelf --version output

# LD_LIBRARY_PATH=lib lib/ld.so.1 ./patchelf  --version
patchelf 0.14.5

Additional context

The last commit in the nixpkgs repo used above is just a bit of paranoia; you can drop that commit and you'll still get the same result.

I discussed this bug here but I'm no longer sure it is the same problem the person who opened that bug was having. In order to avoid hijacking their bug I am opening a separate one now that I have a simple way to reproduce the issue.

[ghost]

Note: if you get a build failure in libredirect, set doInstallCheck=false; in pkgs/build-support/libredirect/libredirect.nix. You might also need to set doCheck=false in openssh/common.nix. Other than these two changes it should build cleanly.

I think these two problems are a result of me just picking a bad day to rebase against master.

[ghost]

This problem also occurs if you try to patchelf --set-interpreter either libc.so or libpthread.so. Fortunately there really is no need for either of these libraries to have an ELF interpreter (unlike ld.so they are not dual-function library-binaries).

[ghost]

I've been attempting to make further progress on this.

Strangely, mips bootstrap-files built at the current nixpkgs HEAD no longer experience this bug. Something changed in glibc between version 2.33 and 2.34.

Edit: the guess below was incorrect

My best guess is the major overhaul of how they handle thread-local storage.

A diff -u <(readelf -a ...) <(readelf -a ...) on the before/after librt.so shows that glibc no longer has the STATIC_TLS flag in the dynamic section:

- 0x000000000000001e (FLAGS)              BIND_NOW STATIC_TLS
+ 0x000000000000001e (FLAGS)              BIND_NOW

And errno@GLIBC_PRIVATE no longer has a weird MIPS-specific relocation type in .rel.dyn:

-Relocation section '.rel.dyn' at offset 0x2488 contains 5 entries:
+Relocation section '.rel.dyn' at offset 0xae0 contains 2 entries:
...
-0000000183a8  000800000030 R_MIPS_TLS_TPREL6 0000000000000000 errno@GLIBC_PRIVATE
-                    Type2: R_MIPS_NONE
-                    Type3: R_MIPS_NONE

I'll keep working on this.

[ghost]

Edit: the guess below was incorrect

More evidence supporting my suspicion: in glibc-2.34:

• librt.so.1 no longer has the STATIC_TLS flag or any R_MIPS_TLS_TPREL6 relocations
• libc.so.6 now has the STATIC_TLS flag and some R_MIPS_TLS_TPREL6 relocations.
• if I adjust nixpkgs' unpack-bootstrap-files.sh script so it patchelfs libc.so.6 (in addition to librt.so.1), the crashing comes back

I strongly suspect that patchelf is mishandling some aspect of STATIC_TLS, most likely the R_MIPS_TLS_TPREL6 relocation.

[ghost]

Woo hoo!