Autoripper should only select ONE Track

[DerPicknicker]

Hello,

first I would like to say thank you for the great Docker-Image. Today I found out that the AutoRipper selects more than one Track. Sometimes on BD-Discs the same Movie is stored as different tracks this causes an Issues, because MakeMKV will select all of them and then you need to select only one. So is there an possibility that the AutoRipper will only select the longest track and not all tracks which have in the most cases the same lengh?

This would help a lot... If you need specific Information just write to me.

[DerPicknicker]

Nobody? Does anyone know where I can make the required changes on my own?

[jlesage]

There is the AUTO_DISC_RIPPER_MIN_TITLE_LENGTH environment variable you can play with.

But if the disc has the same video track twice, I'm not sure how MakeMKV can automatically selects the correct one.

[DerPicknicker]

There is the AUTO_DISC_RIPPER_MIN_TITLE_LENGTH environment variable you can play with.

But if the disc has the same video track twice, I'm not sure how MakeMKV can automatically selects the correct one.

Hello, thank you for your answer... So your docker image should only select the biggest one. I tested it, this works the best. I set the min length to 600sec but the Movie will be ripped twice or four times. I dont know why they put it on the disc more than one time. I guess its just a playlist. So if you can implement a function which forced the autoripper to select only one track and this track should be the biggest track. This would help a LOT...

[jlesage]

MakeMKV doesn't offer the ability to select the "biggest" one. However, the biggest title should also be the longest one.

Did you try to open the disc from the UI to see what's actually inside ? Maybe you can share that so we better understand what is happening.

[DerPicknicker]

I attached an Screenshot. Here you can see that MakeMKV selects all tracks .. The 27,9gb tracks are exact the same lenght... Only the 24gb track is 13min shorter. So the best thing is if MakeMKV selects only the longest track and this Track ONCE ;)

[C4Wiz]

I attached an Screenshot. Here you can see that MakeMKV selects all tracks .. The 27,9gb tracks are exact the same lenght... Only the 24gb track is 13min shorter. So the best thing is if MakeMKV selects only the longest track and this Track ONCE ;)

this is not the containers issue, it's your default selection rules, the behaviour you see above is the default behaviour for makemkv.

see here: https://forum.makemkv.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=4386

[jlesage]

Do you know what is the difference between titles at 27.9GB ?

[C4Wiz]

Do you know what is the difference between titles at 27.9GB ?

yes, all of the 27.9gb tracks are different playlists. IE: 800.mpls, 801.mpls, 802... etc. the difference is the intros and static naming in the movie. in this case the finding nemo title in the video will be in a different lang. each playlist is a different lang. 800.mpls is usually english

[C4Wiz]

the 24.3gb title will not include that intro title mentioned above, nor will it have chapters

[jlesage]

the difference is the intros and static naming in the movie. in this case the finding nemo title in the video will be in a different lang

That what's I thought. In this scenario, I'm not sure if it's possible for MakeMKV to automatically select the correct one.

[DerPicknicker]

Sorry for my late Respond... Yeah for me the biggest one fits the best.. But this must not be a generic thing. So how can this be fixed or lets say how can I prevent this?

Do you know how to set up the MakeMKV-Rules? I read your link but I cannot follow the instructions. Could you help me?

the difference is the intros and static naming in the movie. in this case the finding nemo title in the video will be in a different lang

That what's I thought. In this scenario, I'm not sure if it's possible for MakeMKV to automatically select the correct one.