Add an option to ignore timeouts

[entlicher]

When debugging JUnit tests, they often fails with timeout exception, when timeouts are set for individual methods via @test(timeout=...) annotations. It would be valuable, when debugger could set an option to ignore all test timeouts.
See e.g.: https://netbeans.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=161568

[dsaff]

Can you elaborate? What kind of mechanism would JUnit provide? This isn't
unique to JUnit--any process that spawns a thread and kills it if it seems
to be taking too long would have a similar problem.

David

On Tue, Sep 17, 2013 at 11:58 AM, entlicher [email protected]:

When debugging JUnit tests, they often fails with timeout exception, when
timeouts are set for individual methods via @Testhttps://github.com/Test(timeout=...)
annotations. It would be valuable, when debugger could set an option to
ignore all test timeouts.
See e.g.: https://netbeans.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=161568

—
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com//issues/738
.

[snargleplax]

It could support a command-line option or system property to disable all test timeouts. IDE plugins and build scripts could optionally provide that option when debugging.

[kcooney]

@snargleplax does #956 solve this problem for you?

[entlicher]

Thanks for the DisableOnDebug rule. It's more generic than just timeout handling.
On the other hand, users need to think about it and use it when they write the test. A command-line option could be set by debuggers when launching the test and users would not have to care about it.
Ideally, the time that elaps while the test is suspended by the debugger should be subtracted from the execution time when handling the timeout, but I understand that such a solution is likely out of scope for JUnit.
Maybe, it would be valuable when the timeout is hit and you detect that it's running in a debug mode, print out a suggestion to use DisableOnDebug rule.

[snargleplax]

@kcooney Yes, thanks for the pointer to that. I updated to 4.12-beta-2 and was able to get the behavior I want from DisableOnDebug.

[kcooney]

IDEs and build tools don't use our code to parse flags, so using flags isn't a great option. We could enable features via system properties, but some of the maintainers aren't thrilled with configuration via system properties, and you would have to remember to setup your IDE to set the system property anyway.

If the disable-on-debug feature works well, we could enable it my default in a future JUnit release.

[entlicher]

O.K. Thanks for your comments. And for the DisableOnDebug.

[marcphilipp]

Closing this issue for now.